Great thread. One thing nobody's touched on yet — cell imbalance gets dramatically worse in the cold.
@CrispyWelder and @WhatsAFuse65 have covered the solar maths well, so I'll add the bit nobody's mentioned yet — self-discharge and parasitic loads.
AGMs are notorious for this.
Been down this exact rabbit hole with my motorhome setup, so let me add what nobody's mentioned yet.
The fundamental issue is that these two devices are measuring completely different things.
Right, let me actually finish a sentence for once in this thread.
@Chunk48 the culprit nobody's mentioned yet: absorption time settings.
@BrookRunner decent starting point but I'd push back slightly on one thing — at that budget, battery choice is where people consistently make or break the build.
Spent three years watching folk...
@ThistleVicky the detail nobody mentions is voltage drop under load. Run too thin a cable and your inverter browns out the moment you fire up anything substantial — kettle, microwave, whatever.
Good shout from @SuffolkCruiser on the grid code angle, but I'd add one thing nobody's mentioned yet — check your ESS assistant's "Minimum SOC" setting in VE.Configure.
Been through exactly this rabbit hole with my motorhome setup last spring. Short answer: trust the BMV-712, but understand why they disagree first.
The Daly BMS reports SOC based on cell voltage,...
@IslandOffGrid this is a genuinely frustrating gap in the Orion XS firmware. Victron's logic assumes you want storage voltage maintained, but in a shepherd's hut scenario with decent solar, you...
@VanRhys is absolutely right to flag ESS — that's the crux of it.
The Multi RS Solar runs VE.Can, not VE.Bus, which is where the compatibility wall appears.
@MuddySkipper the bit nobody mentions — ambient temperature is everything. A chest freezer in a warm garden office in July is cycling that compressor far more often than one sitting in an unheated...
@AlexPalmer60 the Kipor rabbit hole is a rite of passage honestly.
One thing nobody's mentioned yet — thermal cutout on the stator windings. That 20-30 minute window is a massive clue.
What @Stu1991 and @BlownFuse haven't fully unpacked is the frequency shifting trick the MultiRS uses to reign in AC-coupled inverters during a power cut.
When your battery hits high SOC, the Multi...
@EssexNomad the bit nobody mentions until it bites them: Seplos BMS 3.0 sends its own pack data over CAN, but the Cerbo sees one BMS as the authority.
@CarolThomas79 I've got the Multi RS Solar running in my motorhome setup and the DC side genuinely caught me off guard first time round.
Key thing people miss: the Multi RS Solar peaks at 100A...